Alternative Therapies, Managing Symptoms
We’re used to thinking of placebos as tricks, pills that don’t contain any active medication disguised as real medicine, used in trials to test whether new treatments actually work. But a recent study published in BMJ Evidence-Based Medicine challenges that assumption.
Researchers looked at whether open-label placebos pills that patients know have no active ingredients could still offer relief for premenstrual syndrome (PMS). And surprisingly, this study found that they could.
What Is an Open-Label Placebo?
An open-label placebo (OLP) is a treatment that contains no active medication, but the person taking it knows that from the start. There’s no deception. The patient is told clearly:
“This pill has no medicine in it, but research shows that some people feel better after taking it.”
The idea seems counterintuitive after all, isn’t the whole point of a placebo that it works because people believe it’s the real thing?
But this growing area of research suggests that the ritual of treatment, the expectation of benefit, and the attention paid to the patient can be powerful enough to create measurable effects — even when the person is in on the secret.
What Did the Study Find?
In this study, women with PMS were randomly assigned to receive either no treatment or an open-label placebo over several menstrual cycles. The group taking the placebo with full transparency that it was inert reported significant reductions in symptoms compared to those who received nothing.
That includes improvements in:
Mood swings
Irritability
Fatigue
Bloating and other physical symptoms
Importantly, these improvements weren’t just reported casually the researchers used validated symptom questionnaires to track changes.
So.. Is It All in Your Head?
That’s the tricky part. The improvements were real, women did feel better but not because the placebo changed hormone levels or addressed the underlying biology of PMS.
Instead, it highlights how:
The brain and body are tightly connected
Expectation and attention can shift perception
Even being part of a study can change how you feel
And no, that doesn’t mean the symptoms were "imaginary." PMS is very real, and for some, debilitating. What this tells us is that symptom experience is complex and how we think and feel about our health can influence how we experience it.
Caution: Not a Cure
It’s important to say: this isn’t a replacement for proper medical treatment. Placebos don’t address the hormonal imbalances, inflammation, or underlying drivers of PMS.
For many people, PMS requires a more comprehensive plan which may include lifestyle changes, psychological support, or medication.
But if you’re someone who wants to avoid medication or has found limited success with traditional options, OLPs might be one small, safe part of a wider toolkit.
Ethical Questions & Real-World Use
The study also opens up an ethical debate: is it okay to “prescribe” placebos, even openly?
Some argue that as long as patients know the truth and consent, it could be a positive, empowering option. Others worry it might blur the line between evidence-based medicine and hopeful guesswork.
Plus, in the real world, people aren’t in research trials. They’re navigating work, childcare, and painful symptoms. Taking a sugary pill every day because it might help isn’t exactly a strong healthcare strategy.
Final Thoughts
This study is fascinating not because it gives us a new treatment, but because it reminds us how complex and powerful our minds are. The placebo effect, even when stripped of secrecy, can still make a difference for some people.
But it’s not a cure, and it’s not a substitute for better PMS treatment options, which remain too limited for too many women.
If anything, this research should push us to ask bigger questions: Why are we still under-treating menstrual health? Why are women often told to “just put up with it”? And how can we create real, respectful, science-based solutions — with or without a sugar pill?
Want to learn more about PMS and women’s health treatments that work? Subscribe to our newsletter or book a consultation with our women's health specialists.